Tesla says New York Times electric car review is ‘fake’

Posted on 14 Feb 2013 at 12:25pm

The former Paypal and Space X founder took to Twitter to defend the Model S after the review said the car ran out of power sooner than expected during a test drive on a cold, winter’s day.

Tesla says the Model S has a range of up to 265 miles (426km) per charge and has sometimes managed more than 300 miles.

Tesla Motors chief executive Elon Musk has branded a New York Times review of his company’s electric saloon car as “fake”.

“NYTimes article about Tesla range in cold is fake,” Mr Musk tweeted.

The NYT defended its article, rebutting Mr Musk’s claim as “flatly untrue”.

Mr Musk claimed the reviewer did not charge the car fully and “took a long detour”.

The NYT reviewer, John Broder, wrote that during the test drive from Washington DC to Connecticut, the power had drained sooner than expected, forcing him to turn down the heating and drive below the speed limit. The car had to be towed to a charging station.

In a statement responding to Mr Musk’s tweets, the NYT said Mr Broder’s review “was completely factual, describing the trip as it occurred. Any suggestion that the account was ‘fake’ is, of course, flatly untrue”.

The range of electric car batteries is known to shrink sometimes in cold weather, as industry experts have discovered.

Last year it failed in its attempt to sue the BBC’s Top Gear having claimed libel and “malicious falsehood” following the TV programme’s 2008 review of its Roadster model.

Tesla’s share price fell 2% after the NYT article appeared on 8 February, but has risen 23.5% over the last 12 months.

Viewing photos

(Read users comments or add a reply)

Tesla Model S
« Prev Photo Next Photo »
Image 1 of 6. Click on image to view full-image/Zoom.
Tesla Model S
« Prev Photo Next Photo »
Image 2 of 6. Click on image to view full-image/Zoom.
Tesla Model S on road
« Prev Photo Next Photo »
Image 3 of 6. Click on image to view full-image/Zoom.
Tesla Model S charging
« Prev Photo Next Photo »
Image 4 of 6. Click on image to view full-image/Zoom.
inside of Tesla Model S
« Prev Photo Next Photo »
Image 5 of 6. Click on image to view full-image/Zoom.
Engine view of 2013 Tesla Model S
« Prev Photo Next Photo »
Image 6 of 6. Click on image to view full-image/Zoom.